Archie McDonald
Archie McDonald
A. Player

probably born in Scotland

Archibald McDonald was born on Saturday, 12th May, 1877, in Kilwinning, North Ayrshire.

The goalkeeper signed for Thistle on Friday, 7th August, 1898, having most recently been with Ayr.

Aged 22, he made his first known appearance on Tuesday, 15th August, 1899, in a 4-3 friendly defeat at home to Clyde.

Archie kept his first known clean-sheet on Saturday, 4th November, 1899, in a 2-0 win away to Airdrieonians in the SFL Second Division.

He registered the last of his 5 known clean-sheets on Monday, 1st January, 1900, in a 5-0 friendly win away to Clachnacuddin.

He played his last known game for the club on Saturday, 17th February, 1900, in a 6-1 defeat at home to Rangers in the Scottish Cup, having appeared for the Thistle on at least 29 occasions.

His club-list included Ayr and Partick Thistle.

Archie died on Monday, 27th May, 1918, in Vancouver, British Columbia, aged 41.

* If you can help us to improve any of these marked points on The Thistle Archive, then please do get in touch →

Archie McDonald's Summary Totals
appearances position won drew lost clean-sheets
League 16 12 1 3 3
Competitive 23 16 1 6 4
All Games 29 18 3 8 5

Bio Extra

The son of Lachlan McDonald (railway surfaceman) and Mary McDonald (née McInnes), who were married in 1873 on the Isle of Mull.

Archie had been keeping goal for Ayr since his late teens, and the 22-year-old arrived at Meadowside in August 1899 as the committee sought a return to the top-flight at the first time of asking. It was his brother, Hugh, who immediately replaced him as Ayr's new #1. Archie endeared himself to the Thistle fans with a match-winning performance against would-be challengers Morton in the first home league game of the season. The crowd (and gate of £63) was disappointing, showing that the public needed more convincing that the poor play of the previous season was a thing of the past. The versatile David Proudfoot scored an early goal but Morton came back strongly and Archie McDonald played well to hold Thistle’s lead. “He is a big fellow with a long reach and a length of leg that could drive the ball almost into the Clyde” is how the Sport described the Thistle keeper. The play wasn’t pretty but Thistle deserved the final score of 2-1. “Every man in the burgh is convinced that the championship flag will find its way to Meadowside” reported the Sport.

The old sibling rivalry always makes for a good story angle. No doubt there’s been a few brotherly contests over the years. The first that we know about in Thistle games occurred on the 23rd September 1899 when Archie McDonald lined up in goals for Thistle in a Second Division match vs. Ayr FC, whilst his brother, Hugh, kept goal for the visitors. It was Archie who won the bragging rights, conceding only once compared to Hugh's four! In fact, Archie was the eldest of three footballing brothers. There was Hugh McDonald (Ayr, Woolwich Arsenal, Brighton & Hove Albion, Oldham Athletic, Bradford Park Avenue, Fulham, Bristol Rovers) as well as John McDonald (Ayr, Blackburn Rovers, Leeds City, Grimsby Town, Queens Park Rangers). Hugh notably had three separate spells at Woolwich Arsenal, being the only player ever to have be signed three times by The Gunners!

As we reached the "business end" of the season, concerns were raised over the quality of goalkeepers at Meadowside. The club did well to reach their third Scottish Cup Quarter Final, but failed to progress in a 1-6 reverse at home to Rangers on 17th February 1900, watched by an excellent crowd of 12,000. Archie lost his place after the big game, and was never seen again for the Jags. John Spence, William Wallace and Daniel Fletcher all took turns as custodian 'til the end of the campaign. Ultimately, the championship flag did find its way to Meadowside, and Archie certainly played his part during his six months with the club. It's not clear what happened to Archie after he left Thistle, perhaps he was scunnered with the game?

In his personal life Archie worked as a stonemason. Whilst a Jag, he married Susan Hall on 22nd December 1899 in Ayr. They had 3 children together, Mary, William & Archibald. The family decided to emigrate to Canada. Archie was first to set sail and in August 1912, Susan and the three children were on the passenger list bound for Quebec. They settled in the Vancouver area. Archie passed away in the springtime of 1918 and was laid to rest in the Mountain View Cemetery in the City of Vancouver, British Columbia. William died in 1920, Susan lived on until 1948 and she too was laid to rest at the Mountain View Cemetery.

(WS/JK/NK)



© The Thistle Archive 2015-2026. All rights reserved. Third-party trademarks and content are the property of their respective owners, and subject to their own copyright terms and conditions. See the website links provided in each case.