J. Howden; John Lyon; J. Wilson; Adam McCall; Donaldson; William Brown; James McGregor In
Willie Howden; Archie McKenzie; Harry Wilson; Bill Gray; Sam Kennedy; Robert Gray; Carrick Hamilton Out
David Melville (1-0, 20 mins); Donaldson (2-1, 2nd half); Adam McCall (3-2, 2nd half) Scorer(s) Hugh Logan (1-1, 1st half); William Tennent (2-2, 2nd half)
Sending Off(s)
probably born in Scotland mh-ptfc-player.png J. Howden Goalkeeper Peter Stewart
probably born in Scotland tom-harvey.jpg Tom Harvey no. 2 John Dunlop
probably born in Scotland john-lyon.jpg John Lyon no. 3 George Higgins
32y, 6m, 7d born in Scotland neilly-gibson.jpg Neilly Gibson no. 4 Robert Hart
born in Scotland david-melville.jpg David Melville no. 5 J. Walker
probably born in Scotland mh-ptfc-player.png J. Wilson no. 6 John Dick
born in Scotland john-lawrie.jpg John Lawrie no. 7 John Clarkson
20y, 5m, 6d born in Scotland mh-ptfc-player.png Adam McCall no. 8 James Logan future Jag
probably born in Scotland mh-ptfc-player.png Donaldson no. 9 William Tennent
born in Scotland mh-ptfc-player.png William Brown no. 10 Hugh Logan
probably born in Scotland mh-ptfc-player.png James McGregor no. 11 William McTaggart
26y, 5m, 22d Age

teamline notes
  • Teamlines per GH.
  • The DR lists a trialist goalkeeper "G. Henderson" and we suspect this is J. Howden (Willie Howden's brother) who is listed in the GH as "Howden Jr.". The DR also list Fleming (not Harvey); David Walker (not J. Wilson) and Milligan (not Donaldson). What can you do?
dubious goals panel
  • We select our goals sequence as per GH, although they only name the first 4 scorers. DR/GH/SC credit David Melville with Thistle's opener, so we're good there. The GH/SC say Donaldson got Thistle's second, but the DR says it was McCall. We stick with Donaldson per the GH/SC for that one on a 2:1 basis. The GH contend that Thistle's third was from a scrimmage, whilst the SC fails to identify the scorer ("a slip by one of the Queens halves gave Thistle the winning goal"). For this one, the DR actually names McCall as scoring his second of the game. On the basis that a named Thistle player is better than a scrimmage we credit Adam McCall as per the DR.

Info match hubs

advertisement

tta.png The Thistle Archive supports the excellent RedYellow.orgexternal-link.png fan initiative - all profits donated to PTFC


ry1.jpg
© The Thistle Archive 2015-2020. All rights reserved. Third-party trademarks and content are the property of their respective owners, and subject to their own copyright terms and conditions. See the website links provided in each case.